Bryan P. Keenan & Associates, PC
Free Initial Consultation
| 412-923-4941
Email Us | Map & Directions
Are You Drowning In Debt?
Don’t wait until it’s too late. declare bankruptcy now!

Supreme Court says debtors cannot appeal bankruptcy denial

On May 4, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that debtors are not entitled to immediately appeal if a bankruptcy court refuses to confirm their proposed repayment plan. The court's unanimous ruling will impact bankruptcy filings in Pennsylvania and across the nation.

On December 14, 2010, the owner of a Randolph, Massachusetts, home voluntarily petitioned the court for a Chapter 13 reorganization of the property's $387,000 mortgage, which is held by Blue Hills Bank. He amended his filing three times over the next two years. His final amendment added a controversial hybrid repayment proposal that split his debt into a secured claim, which was backed by the property, and an unsecured claim. The secured claim would be paid in full over five years, but only a small portion of the unsecured claim was scheduled for repayment. The plan was rejected by Blue Hills Bank, and a bankruptcy court also rejected his plan on July 24, 2012.

The owner appealed, and a bankruptcy appellate panel and a circuit court split over whether he had the right to appeal because the bankruptcy court's rejection was not a final order. However, the bankruptcy court's rejection was ultimately affirmed. He then appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that a "long line of decisions has established that finality in bankruptcy is a broader concept than finality in ordinary civil litigation." The high court ruled that as long as an individual or company remains free to amend a bankruptcy filing, a confirmation rejection is not a final order and cannot be appealed.

This case demonstrates that obtaining court approval for Chapter 13 reorganization can sometimes be a long and complex process. Any debtor who has had their repayment plan rejected by a court may wish to work with an attorney to amend their bankruptcy filing.

Source: Courthouse News Service, "Bankruptcy Plan Appeal Fails to Sway High Court," Dan McCue, May 4, 2015

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Back To Top